An interesting poll was posted at Scrumology asking us to indicate where we consider ‘Agile’ to be on the Hype Cycle. A little note…
The presentation of my framework My.Fragility starts with a general introduction on ‘Agile’ before diving into Scrum and going beyond. This introduction ends with a maturity assessment of Agile using Geoffrey Moore’s Technology Adoption Life Cycle. The conclusion is that Agile has Entered the Bowling Alley (so has definitely Crossed the Chasm).
In 2008 I added a comparison with Gartner’s Hype Cycle for Application Development, which puts Agile in the Trough of Disillusionment and predicts a period of 5-10 years before mainstream adoption.
However, having studied and compared both models I am convinced that Agile is -at least- on its way to the Slope of Enlightenment:
Other objections I have with Gartner are:
- Agile is primarily the common denominator of a number of methods and is as such not one defined method. As a practitioner of Scrum, combining it with XP and going beyond with My.Fragility, I believe these methods to be certainly farther in adoption.
- A complete Agile approach covers a number of practices and disciplines that Gartner separates (e.g. various testing levels). See my indications on the Hype Cycle.
- My intuition and daily experience contradict the 5-10y expectation.
Challenge: from the TALC I expect Scrum to become the Agile Gorilla…
1 thought on “The adoption of Agile: TALC vs. Hype Cycle”
Hope you are doing well, I need some research input for a study based on Offshore Agile software development.
It would be very kind of you if I may be able to get your participations for this research study
The research form could be access at
Your feedback will help me to conclude, which type of the software development is best suitable for offshore and Agile process model, and what kind of developmental strategies a company should adopt in a particular situation, or for a specific project type, for successful development of the offshore software project by using Agile process model.
I will appreciate your contribution and support.